"v21 said @ 1:04am on 4th May - moderate/reply
This is really interesting. I'm not sure if I'm entirely persuaded - but it certainly does change your perspective somewhat. The ploy would only work if gronk was a wolf though, so it's still wise to vote that way.

And there are weirdnesses - like, how come the Thorners were all over Nick? How, other than the revenge on Nick, did the wolves know the Thorners? I suspected at the time that someone had leaked the Thorners identities to the wolves via PM. I still do."

Why do you think it was the wolves specifically that got to BobWTC? I don't follow your connection there, but it seems promising otherwise. A list of possibles, perhaps.

because I'm the seer, used my power to steal kimota's pass and checked all his sent messages.

In all seriousness, gut feeling. I don't think everyone on that list was a wolf, but I have a feeling about the majority.
I think lynching Context is, if not a good move, then at least a logical one. And if he's town too I'd lynch Gronk because he hedged a bet each way. (bob and context)

This assumes that I'm a townie and you're a townie too. If you're a wolf,I suggest you are next to be lynched.
So, are you a wolf?

Yes. Yes I am. You caught me out. Damnit, I'm no good at this game.

But yes, Context seems a bit fishy to me too. Bit I wouldn't mind waiting and killing off a few idlers.

Well I have a good feeling about you, and I assume you have a good feeling about me. But we should both keep in mind the other might be a wolf.
I've never played this game before but I'm addicted already.

Did you read the example game on the signup post? If so, have you followed the second game?

Arrg! So i got your PM and I was like, no, but that seems interesting, and then I was getrting caught up, and then I remembered that I'm at a computer because I have coursework in for a few hours time. So, no, though I have played mafia once before, in real life.

And don't worry, I'm paranoid enough already. But the PM system does make this game more intruiging. The seer should start making a list of trusted villagers, and forming his own little secret society. With cells to disseminate info to non trusted people. But then I guess, how do you know it's him?

For that matter, do we know how many werewolves there are?

I'm guessing there are 4, one on each grouping of 7 and the alpha, because the alpha spot on the other lists is the doctor and the seer.

I actually think the seer should just tell each person he finds innocent. Check this out: If the presumed innocent is actually innocent, then hooray. If they're the alpha, the alpha knows who the seer is when investigated, so it can't make anything worse, right? But after that, cells are the way to go.

Were I a wolf, I would break our pack into two, each latching onto a townsperson, using their votes to direct their own. If one of the wolves turns up on target, they should all try and put suspicion onto the townsperson in that little clique.

If I were a mason or part of the seer confirmed bloc, i'd try a similar tactic.

It's an okay strategy for the masons - assuming there are enough of them (3/2 isn't enough to form a bloc). But the seer's gang should try to be as open as possible once it has the mass - barring the crucial question of who the seer is, of course. If the seer PM's his trusted lieutenants, then they should feel free to PM each other, and announce themselves publicly, and generally be the dudes who are making decent predictions. Sure, that'll be hella suspicious at first, but as soon as one of them gets lynched or savaged or they make a few correct predictions they should be trusted. And as soon as the seer finds a innocent who says he is a mason, then membership can explode. Sure, there's the alpha, but in none of these scenarios does the alpha know any more privileged information than who the seer is. But then, I could see people not going for this, because someones gonna die as part of it. But the advantage is, whoever is the Guardian can find the Seer through his minions (or else the alpha tricks the seer into thinking that he is the guardian - but in this case, the alpha is revealed, and weight of numbers should sort people out by then)

But these plans all require a certain amount of self sacrifice, so they probably won't work. And the whole rigamarole could be set up by a warewolf pretending to be the seer. Damn, that would have been fun. Wish I was a warewolf, now. Oh well.

I'm not quite sure I agree with your reasoning but I can see the merits.

I have a strange feeling about Remiq. I don't know why but something he said on day one made me just go "OMG! ALPHA!!" But then, you know
Paranoia

Well, I thought I was just prejudiced against him due to the whole him wanting to lynch me thing (despite him retracting it when it appeared I wasn't idle). But maybe that was actually suspision. And now he's putting my name forward again. Bleargh, paranoia.

Man, I think I just hopped on a bandwagon. I hope it works.

Jestyr said @ 8:25am on 8th May - moderate/reply
well, I'm gonna go against my gut here.

I vote to lynch LeavemeAlone

even though I have a sudden suspicion about solitude. I know he was cleared by the seer, but since we're dealing with the alpha, that doesn't mean a whole lot.

And if there is a wolf beyond the alpha left, it's pretty much just chance at this point. No one can really trust anyone else, we're all just a bunch of normals vs. a bunch of wolves.